Homes for sale - 262 Sherman Avenue, New Haven, CT 06511

REQUEST A TOUR If you would like to see this home without being there in person, select the "Virtual Tour" option and your agent will contact you to discuss available opportunities.

In-PersonVirtual Tour

Thu

Jan

Fri

Jan

Sat

Jan

HomeSmart Professionals Real Estate

broker@therhodehome.com +1(401) 921-5011

$ 385,000

Est. payment | -/mo

10 Beds

1 Bath

4,598 SqFt

Save

$ 385,000

Est. payment | -/mo

Save

10 Beds

1 Bath

4,598 SqFt

Key Details

Property Type Multi-Family

Sub Type 4 Family

Listing Status Coming Soon

Purchase Type For Sale

Square Footage 4,598 sqft

Price per Sqft $83

MLS Listing ID 24150183

Style Other

Bedrooms 10

Full Baths 1

Year Built 1900

Annual Tax Amount $18,931

Lot Size 7,840 Sqft

Property Sub-Type 4 Family

Property Description

Grand 4,600 sq ft Victorian with Incredible Upside A rare opportunity to complete and customize a truly magnificent Victorian offering approximately 4,600 square feet of living space. The first floor (approx. 1,700 sq ft) features inlaid hardwood floors, a classic fireplace, an updated kitchen and bathroom, and two well-proportioned bedrooms-perfect for immediate use or income while completing the upper levels. Easily convertible to a three bedroom. The second and third floors are fully gutted and partially framed, providing a blank canvas for a buyer with vision. Whether restoring the home's original grandeur or reimagining it for modern living, the heavy lifting has begun and the possibilities are substantial. The property is a legal four-family, and the current owner previously obtained (now expired) permits to convert it to a five-unit property, offering strong future potential for expansion (buyer to perform due diligence). The seller simply doesn't have the bandwidth to take this project on for the next several years and is looking to pass it along to someone ready to bring it across the finish line. Centrally located and convenient to downtown and the Edgewood area, this is an exceptional chance to create a standout investment or showcase residence. With vision and execution, this property could be truly spectacular. SHOWINGS START 1/31/2026

Location

State CT

County New Haven

Zoning RM2

Rooms

Basement Full, Full With Walk-Out

Interior

Heating Hot Air

Cooling None

Exterior

Parking Features Detached Garage, Off Street Parking

Garage Spaces 2.0

Waterfront Description Not Applicable

Roof Type Asphalt Shingle

Building

Lot Description Corner Lot, Level Lot

Foundation Stone

Sewer Public Sewer Connected

Water Public Water Connected

Schools

Elementary Schools Per Board Of Ed

High Schools James Hillhouse

Listed by Michael Martinez • Houlihan Lawrence WD

Nearby Locations

SCHOOLSPROPERTIES

Elementary Schools 20

7

Worthington Hooker School

Public | KG - 8
5

Forest Elementary School

Public | KG - 4
5

Amistad Academy

Public | KG - 12
4

May V. Carrigan Intermediate School

Public | 5 - 6
4

Mauro - Sheridan Interdistrict Magnet School

Public | PK - 8
4

Betsy Ross Arts Magnet School

Public | 5 - 8
4

Church Street School

Public | PK - 6
4

Lincoln - Bassett Community School

Public | PK - 6
4

Highville Charter School

Public | PK - 9
4

Conte/West Hills Magnet School

Public | PK - 8
4

John S. Martinez School

Public | KG - 8
4

Christopher Columbus Academy

Public | PK - 8
3

Davis Academy for Arts & Design Innovation Magnet School

Public | PK - 8
3

Wintergreen Interdistrict Magnet School

Public | KG - 8
3

Edgewood Magnet School

Public | KG - 8
3

Helen Street School

Public | PK - 6
3

John C. Daniels School

Public | PK - 8
3

East Rock Community & Cultural Studies Magnet School

Public | PK - 8
2

Brennan Rogers School

Public | PK - 8
2

King / Robinson Interdistrict Magnet School

Public | PK - 8

Middle Schools 3

6

Engineering - Science University Magnet School

Public | 6 - 11
0

Hopkins School

Private | 7 - 12
0

Cedarhurst School

Private | 6 - 12

High Schools 16

6

Sound School

Public | 9 - 12
5

Cooperative High School

Public | 9 - 12
4

Common Ground High School

Public | 9 - 12
4

Hill Regional Career High School

Public | 9 - 12
2

Metropolitan Business High School

Public | 9 - 12
2

Hyde Leadership School

Public | 9 - 12
2

New Haven Academy

Public | 9 - 12
2

Wilbur Cross High School

Public | 9 - 12
1

Eli Whitney Technical High School

Public | 9 - 12
1

James Hillhouse High School

Public | 9 - 12
1

High School in the Community

Public | 9 - 12
0

Chapel Haven School

Private | 12 - 12
0

Notre Dame High School

Private | 9 - 12
0

Riverside Education Academy

Public | 9 - 12
0

Yeshiva Beis Dovid Shlomo

Private | 9 - 12
0

Polly T. Mccabe Center

Public | 9 - 12

School and business data provided by Attom Data.

Helping real estate be fast, fun and stress-free!

+1(401) 921-5011

broker@therhodehome.com

100 Quaker Lane, Warwick, RI, 02886

262 Sherman Avenue New Haven, CT 06511